Top Picks: The 5 Best Small Bars in Bethlehem PA

I’ve always been a sucker for cozy spots where the drinks flow as freely as the conversations. That’s why I set out on a mission to uncover the best small bars in Bethlehem, PA. Trust me, this historic town is brimming with hidden gems that are just waiting to be discovered.

From quirky dives to sophisticated speakeasies, Bethlehem’s bar scene is as diverse as it is vibrant. I was thrilled to dive into the heart of this city, sampling unique cocktails and local brews, all while soaking in the intimate atmospheres that make each spot truly special. Join me as I share my top picks for the must-visit small bars in Bethlehem, PA.

McCarthy’s Red Stag Pub and Whiskey Bar

When I first stepped into McCarthy’s Red Stag Pub and Whiskey Bar, I knew I’d found somewhere special. Nestled in the heart of Bethlehem, this cozy spot whisked me away to the heart of Ireland without ever leaving Pennsylvania. The ambiance is exactly what you’d imagine for a place that prides itself on its extensive whiskey selection: dark wood, tartan accents, and soft lighting that invites you to settle in for the evening.

Ambiance here is key. It isn’t just about the physical decor; it’s the Irish pub aura that envelopes you the moment you walk in. With live music on most weekends, enhancing the immersive experience. It’s easy to lose track of time in such a welcoming atmosphere, especially when you’re tucked into a snug corner with friends or settling in at the bar to make some new ones.

The service at McCarthy’s Red Stag is top-notch. Staff are not only friendly but incredibly knowledgeable about their whiskey selections and the stories behind them. They’ve guided me through their impressive collection, helping me discover new favorites and reacquaint with classic drams. Their passion is contagious, making each visit not just a night out, but a learning experience.

Let’s talk about the food because it’s impossible not to. The menu is a perfect marriage of traditional Irish and British fare. Each dish is crafted with care, and you can taste the quality in every bite. From the authentic Fish and Chips or the Guinness Mac and Cheese to the perfectly cooked, melt-in-your-mouth Faroe Island Salmon, there’s something to satisfy every palate.

Lastly, the location of McCarthy’s Red Stag could not be more perfect. Situated in the bustling heart of Bethlehem, it’s easily accessible, yet feels like a hidden retreat once you’re inside. Its proximity to local shops and other attractions makes it an ideal starting or ending point for an evening of exploration in this historic town.

My visits to McCarthy’s Red Stag Pub and Whiskey Bar have always been about more than just finding a place to enjoy a drink. They’ve been journeys that explore the rich tapestry of Scottish culture, right here in Bethlehem. The combination of ambiance, service, food, and location makes for an unforgettable experience that keeps me coming back.

Social Still Distillery

Across the river from McCarthy’s, about a 5-minute drive, you’ll find the Social Still Distillery. The moment I stepped inside, I knew I was in for a treat.

When you step into this prohibition-era bank, you’ll find yourself in a place where production and hospitality collide. The venue seamlessly blends old-school vibes with contemporary twists. With soaring ceilings and crisp, clean lines, the decor is both cool and classy. Whether you’re a history enthusiast or simply appreciate unique spaces, the tasting room at Social Still will captivate you.

The staff at Social Still is friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. They create an inviting atmosphere, making you feel right at home. Whether you’re a seasoned spirits connoisseur or a curious first-timer, they’ll guide you through the experience with genuine warmth.

The menu is a genuine treat where it is hard to go wrong. Check out the Truffled Fries, delicious Short Ribs or treat yourself to one of their delightful salmon.

Crafting a Revolution in Spirits

Social Still Micro Distillery and Kitchen sources local grains, mashes, and ferments them right on-site. Their premium spirits are distilled using a pot still, reminiscent of the methods used by our ancestors. From small-batch vodka to whiskey and bourbon, each sip tells a story of craftsmanship and passion.

Whether you’re sipping a handcrafted cocktail, exploring their infused vodkas and gins, or simply enjoying the ambiance, Social Still promises an unforgettable experience. So, gather your friends, raise your glasses, and toast to the art of distillation at this remarkable establishment!

Located in the heart of Bethlehem, Social Still benefits from being easily accessible while feeling like an escape from the ordinary. Nestled among quaint shops and historic buildings, it stands as a testament to Bethlehem’s vibrant and evolving food and drink scene. Its location not only makes it a convenient stop during a night out in town but also contributes to the unique character that makes Social Still a must-visit destination.

The Wooden Match

Stepping into the heart of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, I found myself at The Wooden Match, a gastropub that stands out for its unique blend of history, hospitality, and culinary delight. Nestled in a beautifully restored train depot, this place offered me an experience far from the ordinary, with an atmosphere that felt both inviting and intriguing, with live music during warmer months.

The Wooden Match sits at 61 W Lehigh St, just a short walk from the vibrant downtown area. Its historical essence is palpable, from the architecture that whispers tales of the past to the old train tracks that add a layer of nostalgia. The ambiance inside is warm and welcoming, oozing a rustic charm that I instantly fell in love with. Outdoor seating is also available and smoking is permitted.

What sets The Wooden Match apart isn’t just its status as a gastropub but its identity as a cigar bar as well. This unique aspect allowed me the freedom to enjoy a cigar at my leisure, blending the pleasure of smoking with dining. However, for those who might find the aroma of cigars less appealing, the outdoor dining area offered a perfect retreat, proving that The Wooden Match caters to all preferences.

During my visit, I was struck by the friendliness and efficiency of the service. The staff was attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience that made me feel well taken care of. Though I heard there might be occasional lapses in service, my experience was nothing short of excellent.

The menu was a delightful journey through a great menu of American cuisine, focusing on burgers, sandwiches, and classic pub food with amazing appetizers as well as delicious steaks. I couldn’t resist the Angels and Demons and Mule Kick Burger, both of which came highly recommended and did not disappoint. The homemade chips were a crunchy, savory treat that complemented my meal perfectly. For seafood lovers, the Crab Cakes and Football are a must-try, while the Ribeye stood out as a hearty choice for those craving something more substantial. Vegetarians weren’t left out, with options that catered to their dietary preferences.

The Wooden Match’s pride in its extensive selection of craft beers was evident. The rotating draft beer selection promised something new with each visit, inviting patrons to explore and enjoy a variety of brews.

In conclusion, The Wooden Match is more than a gastropub. It’s a sanctuary for those looking to unwind, socialize, and indulge in good food and drink. Whether you’re a Bethlehem local or just passing through, The Wooden Match is a place that promises a memorable dining experience. My visit was an affirmation of its special place in Bethlehem’s culinary and social landscape, and I’m already looking forward to my next visit.

The Nest Bar & Grille

In another one of my visits to Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, I stumbled upon a gem that genuinely stands apart from your typical sports bar – The Nest Bar & Grille. Nestled at 601 E 4th St, this spot merges the love for sports, scrumptious food, and an array of drinks into a compelling experience that beckons every passerby.

The Nest is a stone’s throw from the bustling heart of Bethlehem, making it a convenient haunt for both locals and visitors. The ambiance is vibrant and welcoming, the kind of place that feels just right for catching a Sunday game or enjoying a night out with friends. Adding to its charm is the pet-friendly outdoor seating area, allowing me and my furry companion to bask in the open air while indulging in the culinary delights.

One of the Nest’s crowning jewels is its dedicated second floor, aptly named the Eagles Nest. This exclusive nook caters to Philadelphia sports enthusiasts, offering a sense of belonging and camaraderie that’s hard to find elsewhere.

The service here is nothing short of remarkable. The staff’s friendliness and efficient service made me feel right at home. They’re not just service providers; they’re enthusiasts with a wealth of knowledge about the menu and the bar’s rich history, enhancing the overall dining experience.

The Nest’s menu is a treasure trove of classic sports bar staples – wings, tuna nachos, sandwiches, burgers, and egg rolls, each more tempting than the last. The wings, slathered in an array of flavorful sauces, were an instant hit for me, while the nachos emerged are a perfect companion for a group outing. The burgers, juicy and satisfying, came with a side of homemade chips, embodying the essence of comfort food. You can also choose from other amazing options such as turkey burgers, chicken sandwiches and shrimp tacos.

The Nest Bar & Grille is more than just a venue to watch the game. It’s a sanctuary where great food, exemplary service, and a dynamic atmosphere converge to create unforgettable moments. Whether you’re a die-hard sports fan or in search of a vibrant spot for a night out, The Nest in Bethlehem, PA, is a must-visit. My visit there was not just about watching the game; it was an experience that left me looking forward to my next visit.

Joe’s Tavern

As I walked into Joe’s Tavern, located at 12 W Broad St in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, I was immediately struck by the lively atmosphere. The bar was buzzing with energy, and the sound of friendly chatter filled the air.

The location of Joe’s Tavern is perfect, right in the heart of Bethlehem. The ambiance is casual and inviting, making it a great place to unwind after a long day. The tavern is small and quaint, giving it a cozy feel. I particularly enjoyed the open-concept door that lets in fresh air during the summer.

Service The service at Joe’s Tavern was top-notch. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure that I had everything I needed. They were knowledgeable about the menu and were able to answer all my questions.

The menu at Joe’s Tavern is diverse and very reasonable in price, offering a range of dishes to suit different tastes. I decided to try their famous cheesesteak, and I was not disappointed. The steak was tender and flavorful, and the cheese was perfectly melted. I also tried their homemade soup, which was absolutely delicious. Other options that I need to try next time are the 1/2 pound burger or the fish tacos!

In addition to their food, Joe’s Tavern also offers a great selection of craft beers. You’ll never run out of beers and drinks to try

My visit to Joe’s Tavern was a memorable one. The combination of the welcoming atmosphere, excellent service, and delicious food made for a fantastic dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just visiting Bethlehem, PA, I highly recommend stopping by Joe’s Tavern1.

Conclusion

In the bustling culinary scene of Bethlehem, there’s a wealth of bars and restaurants just waiting to be discovered, and these lesser-known spots are some of my personal favorites. Each one offers something unique, ensuring that no matter where you decide to go, you’re in for a treat. Whether it’s the cozy vibe of a tucked-away tavern, the lively atmosphere of an under-the-radar sports bar, or the distinct charm of a hidden gastropub, each location promises a memorable experience. So, as you explore Bethlehem’s culinary landscape, be prepared to find delightful surprises and new favorites among these gems!