Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, is a hidden gem with a rich history and a lively culinary scene. One of my favorite ways to explore this charming city is by indulging in its fantastic ice cream offerings. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, here are some must-visit spots that promise to satisfy your ice cream cravings.
1. Bethlehem Dairy Store
First up is the Bethlehem Dairy Store, an iconic establishment that has been a local favorite for over 85 years. As soon as you step inside, the nostalgia hits you. The friendly staff, the array of classic flavors, and the old-school charm make it a must-visit spot. Whether you’re indulging in a scoop of their creamy vanilla or trying a seasonal special, you can’t go wrong here. This place is perfect for a family outing or simply reliving childhood memories.
2. Stations Cafe
Next on my list is Stations Cafe, located in the heart of historic downtown Bethlehem. While not exclusively an ice cream parlor, this cozy cafe offers a variety of treats, including some seriously good ice cream. I love stopping by for a scoop (or two) after enjoying one of their fresh, healthy meals. The relaxed atmosphere makes it an ideal spot to unwind and enjoy a sweet treat.
3. Dave’s Deli & Gelato
If you’re a gelato enthusiast like me, Dave’s Deli & Gelato is a little slice of heaven. This charming deli is known for its homemade gelato, which is incredibly rich and flavorful. The first time I tried their pistachio gelato, I was instantly transported to the streets of Italy. They have a rotating selection of flavors, so there’s always something new and exciting to try. It’s the perfect stop for a midday treat or an after-dinner dessert.
4. The Cup (Formerly Bethlehem Dairy Store)
The Cup is another beloved spot in Bethlehem, famous for its milkshake cup shape. This place has been delighting locals and visitors alike for years. With two year-round locations, you can enjoy their delicious ice cream anytime. The variety of flavors and treats available here is impressive. Whether you’re craving a classic cone or an indulgent sundae, The Cup has got you covered.
5. Geaker’s Tacos
Now, you might not immediately think of tacos when you’re on the hunt for ice cream, but Geaker’s Tacos is here to surprise you. Known primarily for their delicious tacos, they also serve up some tasty ice cream. It’s a unique combination that intrigued me at first, but once I tried it, I was hooked. It’s a fun and unexpected spot to enjoy a savory meal followed by a sweet dessert.
Best Vegan Ice Cream Options in Bethlehem
For those of us who prefer or require vegan options, Bethlehem doesn’t disappoint. Here are some fantastic spots offering delicious vegan ice cream.
1. Vegan Treats
Vegan Treats is an absolute must-visit if you’re in Bethlehem. Known for their decadent vegan desserts, cakes, and pastries, their soft-serve ice cream is equally impressive. Every time I visit, I’m amazed by how creamy and flavorful their vegan ice cream is. It’s a guilt-free indulgence that anyone can enjoy.
2. VegOut
VegOut started as a pop-up and has now become a beloved all-vegan spot in Bethlehem. Their menu is full of vegan delights, and their ice cream is no exception. I love the weekly rotating desserts, which means there’s always something new and exciting to try. It’s a fantastic spot for those who love variety and high-quality vegan treats.
3. Stations Cafe
Stations Cafe also caters to vegan ice cream lovers with their locally made vegan options. Their commitment to fresh, healthy, and natural food extends to their desserts, making it a great spot for anyone seeking vegan treats. It’s one of my favorite places to relax and enjoy a scoop of delicious vegan ice cream.
4. De Novo Creamery
Last but certainly not least, De Novo Creamery specializes in vegan ice cream cakes and small-batch, slow-churn vegan ice cream by the pint. Their creative flavors and dedication to quality make them a standout choice for vegan ice cream lovers. I highly recommend trying their unique and delicious offerings.
Conclusion
Bethlehem, PA, is home to a delightful array of ice cream shops, each offering something unique and delicious. Whether you’re in the mood for traditional flavors, creamy gelato, or vegan treats, these local spots have got you covered. So, grab a friend, head out, and embark on an ice cream adventure in Bethlehem. You won’t be disappointed!
Christopher Smith, the publisher of this website is a lifetime lover of music, great food, fishing and local bars. After moving to the Lehigh Valley in 1992, he quickly discovered the charm of Historic Bethlehem, also known as Christmas City, with it's cobblestone streets, amazing restaurants, Artsquest and of course, Musikfest.
While living in the Reading area for the past 25 years, Christopher frequently ventured back to the Bethlehem for Musikfest, fishing the Lehigh, floating the Delaware River and exploring the Monocacy Creek, as well as enjoying many of the bars and restaurants he loves.
Having moved back to the area recently, you will find him fishing the Lehigh for smallmouth bass, frequenting Tapas On Main, enjoying the Pan Seared Scallops at the Apollo Grill or sipping an Old Fashioned at McCarthy's.
Join him as he shares his love for Bethlehem and the evolution of a city built on silk and steel, but transformed into a modern oasis of fun that offers enjoyment and excitement for everyone.